(No Title)

Defining Fascism

I think it’s past time for me to better define terms I use in my rants to draw comparisons between the political and social events/philosophies/ideologies of our time and those of history. Specifically, I’ve been lazy about using the terms “Fascism” and “Nazism” frequently AND interchangeably. I’ve been making plenty of these kinds of statements, especially post-9/11. Deep down, I’m personally disgusted with myself when I make all these Nazi comparisons. I consider them rather intellectually lazy, at the least, and at worst indicative of poor/lazy writing – a major failure in someone who prides himself on his ability to speak and write well. Yup, I’ve been pretty damn lazy and untrue to myself.

But regardless of my discomfort with it, the similarities are just too striking and too real and too disturbing. I’m trying not to be too hard on myself and acknowledge that what we are experiencing in American society and politics is nothing less than the re-emergence of Fascism and the destruction of our democracy, and that we are at a point on a road far, far removed from the American Revolution and the concepts of Fraternity, Equality and Liberty. (And yes, I know that’s a French motto. Sue me.) This all didn’t happen recently.

It’s just that, in order to live with my conscience, it’s time to get more honest and less lazy and cast daily events/quotes in terms of how they relate to specific criteria set forth in a definition of generic Fascism before I shoot off my mouth. I’ll also try to reduce comparisons to the NSDAP of 1919-45 somewhat. There are plenty of striking similarities between the American corporate oligarchy that I’m always ranting about and the history of Fascism that, if we forget it, we’re doomed to repeat it. Besides, it didn’t take all that much effort to do a web search and do my homework and be more intellectually honest.

It would seem to be nearly impossible to separate the NSDAP and fascism. But truthfully, fascism, in the modern sense as relevant to today’s situation, was defined and put in practice first in Italy. Mussolini himself wrote a definition of the term. Modern fascism, which appeared to reach its acme with the Axis powers of the period, was not, in fact, vanquished on VE day in 1945.

(An aside: Fascism derives from the Roman fasces, the bundle of rods and ax that served as the symbol of the power of the Roman state in ancient times. Symbols are enormously important in Fascist states.)

On the website Remember.org, home of the “Cybrary of the Holocaust,” it’s noted that Fascism and Nazism share, to varying degrees, several distinguishing characteristics:

“1. Nationalism and super-patriotism with a sense of historic mission.

“2. Aggressive militarism even to the extent of glorifying war as good for the national or individual spirit.

“3. Use of violence or threats of violence to impose views on others (fascism and Nazism both employed street violence and state violence at different moments in their development).

“4. Authoritarian reliance on a leader or elite not constitutionally responsible to an electorate.

“5. Cult of personality around a charismatic leader.

“6. Reaction against the values of Modernism, usually with emotional attacks against both liberalism and communism.

“7. Exhortations for the homogeneous masses of common folk (Volkish in German, Populist in the U.S.) to join voluntarily in a heroic mission, often metaphysical and romanticized in character.

“8. Dehumanization and scapegoating of the enemy, seeing the enemy as an inferior or subhuman force, perhaps involved in a conspiracy that justifies eradicating them.

“9. The self image of being a superior form of social organization beyond socialism, capitalism and democracy.

“10. Elements of national socialist ideological roots, for example, ostensible support for the industrial working class or farmers; but ultimately, the forging of an alliance with an elite sector of society.

“11. Abandonment of any consistent ideology in a drive for state power.“

The writers go on to note that “what distinguishes Nazism from generic fascism is its obsession with racial theories of superiority, and some would say, its roots in the socialist theory of proletarian revolution.“

Comparisons between the contemporary American white supremacist movement and the NSDAP are indeed valid ones to make then; this domestic movement itself invokes and honors images/descriptions/names of the Third Reich, so I feel it’s not particularly weak of me to make such comparisons myself when writing about the KKK, for example.

But other than that, from here on out, I’ll try, other than where appropriate, to resist making too many Nazi comparisons in my rants, and rely more on framing my comments in terms of how our political and social climate in America today matches up with the specific 11 characteristics of Fascism listed above.

More on this tomorrow; I’ll try to give specific ways that America now meets each of those 11 criteria for being a Fascist state. It does, folks. But for now, it’s after 1 a.m., and I must to bed.

Good night, ya’ll.

Bluesky Discussion

View on Bluesky

No replies yet. Be the first to comment on Bluesky!