Requiem For The First Amendment
This is what political life in the Empire has become. Last month’s Portland protests were simply a harbinger of things to come, it would appear.
For instance, don’t plan on protesting crass political, personal gain in South Bend:
‘Protesters will not get close enough to Century Center, site of the fund-raiser for Chocola, to see the president or be seen by him. But they still will seek attention of the news media as they gather in sites nearby. No group has indicated the desire for anything other than a peaceful presentation of dissenting views on matters from trade abroad to Social Security proposals at home.
‘U.S. Rep. Tim Roemer, D-South Bend, who now represents the area that has become a political battleground, criticized the president’s role as fund-raiser-in-chief, with photos with [the Boy Emperor] going for $4,000 Thursday night at a dinner for Republican congressional nominee Chris Chocola.
‘Roemer said [the Boy Emperor] had campaigned on “restoring dignity and responsibility to the White House.” Instead, the congressman contended, the $4,000 photos mean that Chocola is exploiting the White House “for crass political, personal gain.”
‘The [Boy Emperor] should instead be willing to have his photo taken “for free as a public servant,” especially at a time of unemployment and other economic woes, Roemer said.‘
Well, yes, but that’s just typical. The Boy Emperor is a fundraising machine. His corporate paymasters know he’ll do whatever they want … and he’ll do it cheap – or cheap, that is, in comparison to what they get in return.
Boy Emperor, thy name is whore.
But I digress. The true issue here is about expression of dissent, supposedly a much-cherished Amurrican tradition.
But wait. I guess it’s actually not all that cherished anymore, eh?
‘Support for the First Amendment has eroded significantly since Sept. 11 and nearly half of Americans now think the constitutional amendment on free speech goes too far in the rights it guarantees, says a poll … The sentiment that the First Amendment goes too far was already on the rise before the terrorist attacks a year ago, doubling to four in 10 between 2000 and 2001. The poll found that 49 percent think the First Amendment goes too far, a total about 10 points higher than in 2001.
‘They found that 48 percent of respondents agreed the government should have the freedom to monitor religious groups in the interest of national security – even if that means infringing upon the religious freedom of the group’s members. Forty-two percent said the government should have more authority to monitor Muslims.
‘The survey also found a significant dip in the number of people who believe newspapers should freely criticize the U.S. military about its strategy and performance. Fifty-seven percent were supportive this year, compared to 69 percent in 2001. Seven in 10 respondents agreed newspapers should publish freely, a slight drop from 2001. Those less likely to support newspaper rights included people without a college education, Republicans, and evangelicals, the survey found.
‘Republican respondents also were more likely than Democrats or Independents to see the news media as too aggressive in seeking war information from government officials.‘
Well, isn’t that just completely lovely? Isn’t the future going to be just completely peachy keen?
Well, folks, that future is here. And it brings to mind that old quote from Benjamin Franklin, ‘Those that would give up liberty for a little security deserve neither‘
So I guess we’re simply getting what we deserve, eh? Witness what happened in Pennsylvania on Labor Day:
‘I got a first-hand lesson on Labor Day on what the right to freedom of speech and freedom of assembly mean under the regime of George W. Bush. Americans who support Bush and his policies can raise signs in his praise and line the streets when his limousine passes by. Americans who do not support Bush and his policies must stay far away from the president by judicial decree or risk arrest.
‘That’s what happened to a small but committed band of demonstrators who wanted to exercise their First Amendment rights at a by-invitation-only appearance by Bush at a picnic sponsored by the United Brotherhood of Carpenters and Joiners at Neville Island, PA, just down the Ohio River from Pittsburgh. The Carpenters and Teamsters Unions are the only labor organizations to support Bush.
‘While between 200 and 300 invited guests filed into the picnic grounds, police ordered between 60 and 70 protesters to stay four blocks away inside a sun-baked, chain-link fence-surrounded park. Anyone with a protest sign who stood one foot outside that fence would be arrested. A 65-year-old man who did stand just outside that fence with a sign was, in fact, arrested, along with his sister, who came to his assistance when Allegheny County police put handcuffs on him.
…
‘I later found out how many of those who attended the picnic got their tickets. A large number went to members of the carpenters union, of course. GOP candidates for local, state, and federal office got tickets, along with their supporters. The third group consisted local residents. One of them, a woman named Mary, told me that Secret Service agents knocked on the doors of all the houses near the picnic area. The residents had two choices: accept the tickets or face a form of house arrest. Township residents could also get tickets by going to the police station.
‘Michael Rechtenwald, founder and chair of Citizens for Elected Government, who had called the Freedom Zone “pathetic and a violation of the Constitution of the United State,” soon joined us. He carried a small sign bearing the logo of his organization. No inflammatory phrases. No insults. Just the title, “Citizens for Legitimate Government.” Within minutes, an angry looking Secret Service agent in a blue suit and two uniformed police office bore down on him. Unlike the uniformed police I had dealt with thus far, this man was not polite.‘
‘“You know where the protest area is,” he told Rechtenwald. “You know where you’re supposed to be.” When Rechtenwald quietly said he was merely exercising his First Amendment rights, the Secret Service agent replied, “Now you REALLY are pushing it.” The agent warned Rechtenwald in no uncertain terms that, unless he left the area, he was “this close” to being arrested for violating a federal protection order, a felony offense. The agent then told Rechtenwald that two state troopers would escort him back to “the pen” and that if he said a single word, he would be arrested on a felony charge. “If I so much as say a thing, these guys will arrest me?” Rechtenwald asked. “Yes!” declared the agent with serious conviction. Rechtenwald wisely left the area.
‘Throughout this entire confrontation, we could hear Bush’s audience cheer and applaud as he used the all too familiar phrases, “homeland security,” and “our enemies wish to take away our freedoms.” I wondered who had just taken away Michael Rechtenwald’s freedom of speech.
And that eloquent account can stand on its own without any additional comment from me.
Good night ya’ll.