First Do No Harm
Not for the squeamish is this article on Salon entitled, “A Doctor’s Right To Choose.” Yet, it’s one of the most detailed, direct and honest descriptions of what actually happens during various kinds of abortion I’ve read in quite some time. Written by journalist Margaret A. Woodbury, the article particularly cuts through all the emotional politics surrounding the issue – particularly the sub-issue of the misnamed-for-political-purposes “partial-birth” abortion, which is properly known as “dilation and extraction,” or “D&X,” which is obviously a too clinical and dispassionate name for those on the anti-Roe side of the cultural divide.
(Fair warning: The following contains quotes from the article, including rather graphic descriptions of abortion.)
During a D&X, “… the not-yet-viable fetus is removed from the uterus as a whole, except for the fetal skull, which is collapsed via a cervical incision and suction rather than crushed with forceps. In this procedure, say those who defend it, there is no fragmentation of bone, which minimizes the risk to the woman. For this reason, say proponents, intact dilation and extraction significantly reduces the number of times that potentially damaging instruments are introduced into the uterus; it prevents certain medical complications to the woman, such as uterine perforation; reduces the likelihood of retained fetal parts in the womb, which can lead to infection; and, finally, as a shorter procedure, it allows for less bleeding and a lower risk of infection.”
Compare that to the usual abortion procedure, which is called D&E – Dilation and Evacuation, during which “the doctor terminates the pregnancy by dismembering the fetus inside the uterus or as it is extracted from the uterus into the vagina. The fetal skull, which after approximately 16 weeks of pregnancy is too large to pass through a cervix that is only partially dilated, is crushed with forceps prior to extraction from the uterus. Fetal bones begin to calcify at about 17 weeks of pregnancy, so with each dismembered fetal part comes the attached risk of injury to the woman of uterine tears or perforations by bony fragments, as well as the possibility of leaving a fetal fragment inside the uterus – something one district court judge called a ‘horrible complication.’”
Yet, as the article points out, it’s the D&X procedure on which Roe foes have chosen to concentrate their ire and fire. The term “partial birth abortion” “became ingrained in the public debate, and helped shift the focus of antiabortion activists from opposing women’s health-and-reproductive rights to supporting fetal rights.” Which is, I suppose pretty typical of the quality of the usual rightwing debate – hysterical knee-jerking without seriously thinking through the logic and science of something.
The real issue, according to Woodbury, boils down to: “As the debate has raged for nearly a decade, doctors and pro-choice activists who support the legal option of abortion by intact dilation and extraction argue that, because the end result of an abortion is always the end of a pregnancy, it should be the goal of the surgeon to deliver the best possible care to the woman as he or she accomplishes that task. The debate over when life begins may never be settled, they argue, but the issue of the woman’s relative health can be medically determined.”
Well, exactly. In other words, at this point in time, abortion is a legal procedure, and therefore, the safest abortion method should be used. The health of women shouldn’t be used as cannon fodder in the culture war.
So, in spite of my own squeamishness on this issue, I agree. If the “law of the land” is that pregnant women have the Constitutional right to end their pregnancy in a medically safe, secure and supportive environment, then so be it.
But let me be clear about my own position. I do believe life begins at conception. Yet, the issue is not just that simple. For one thing, I don’t believe that government, the courts, rightwing politicians or the sanctimonious hypocrites in organized religion have any business dictating that abortion should be unavailable to anyone for any reason. I do believe abortions should be safe and legal – but very rare.
There are valid reasons for abortion in certain cases. I.e., can you imagine what some southern, rightwing, funDumbmentalist like Jerry Falwell or Jesse Helms would do if their own daughter was brutally raped by a (gasp! horrors!) black man – and it resulted in a perfectly formed, viable fetus who would grow up half-African-American, born of violence, and calling Jerry or Jesse “Grampa”? You better believe they’d take advantage of “safe and legal” before their precious daughter even left the hospital after the rape. And of course, just like George W. Bush did, they’d cover it all up, post haste, and continue the anti-Roe crusade.
Ultimately, it’s the hypocrisy of the anti-Roe crowd that forces me into the position where I believe conception produces life, but also believe abortion should be safe, legal and rare.
After all, is that really any more contradictory or hypocritical than an anti-abortion zealot who bombs clinics to prevent “murders of children,” – but after that child is born, pursues policies that keep him ignorant, in poverty, unloved, lacking in medical care, unfed at school, suspected of delinquency and indefinitely incarcerated for the slightest infraction of law?
Because there’s the rub. The rightwing conservative position is that of pulsating hypocrisy: Don’t give anyone contraceptives (or even information on them), then, when a woman gets pregnant, don’t kill the child in the womb, but let it die from neglect after birth, or, if it does something seriously criminal because it’s uneducated, poor and oppressed, inject it with chemicals and kill it. Call abortion of a fetus “murder,” but call official state homicide of a inmate “capital punishment.”
There’s a real disconnect here, folks.
There’s actually some evidence to support a safe, legal and rare position: Between 1990-99, the numbers of abortions to decrease (an estimated 300,000-500,000 LESS abortions occurred during the Clinton/Gore years than in the Reagan/Bush years). In addition, there were increased numbers of adoptions; the lowest teen birth rate in 60 years; and the lowest infant mortality rate in American history. Of course, none of that means anything ’cause Bill got a blow job. But still.
It’s an extremely tough issue and I don’t pretend to have any clarity on the issue. No one can, I think, claim to know the real truth. Conception is just as complex and almost as unknowable as what happens at death: No one has ever given detailed reports or evidence as to what happens during either. Which is why, I suppose, neither process should be dictated by the powerful or the religious.
Good night ya’ll.
![]()