What’s Going On Here?!
I was searching online for a different topic, but ran across, by accident, abstracts for student experiments from the 2002 California State Science Fair. Now, first let me say, congratulations to the kids and their hard work and effort. Nothing personal is intended here and certainly no bad reflection on their efforts.
But what is wrong with this friggin’ society??!! Science Fair is apparently no longer about science, but all about … corporate brands.
Of the 42 projects in the abstract document, exactly half (21) set out to determine whether one brand of something was better than the other, to wit:
– WD-40 was the best lubricant with the lowest friction.
– Orville Redenbacker’s microwave popcorn is more energy-efficient than Jolly Time stove-top popcorn.
– Pro Liquid Drain Opener was the best drain opener; Zep was second, Drano Max third and Liquid Plumber last.
– S&W brand canned corn was the most truthful brand in label nutrition facts; only FMV and Heritage brands weighed the labeled amount; and Del Monte was the best tasting.
– Porcelain bowls were the best vegetable containers, followed by Tupperware brand, Ziplock baggies, Saran Wrap and then plastic cups.
– Modacrylic brand fabric is the slowest burning synthetic fiber.
– Formica brand counter tops had higher resistance to peanut oil penetration, which is important to people with peanut allergies.
– Dawn dishwashing detergent cleans the most oil from feathers, followed by Johnson’s Baby Shampoo, followed by SoftSoap.
– Energizer battery made the most mechanical energy, followed by Eveready.
– Purell, Bath and Body Works and Alcare Pluse were not very effective in killing bacteria. Aloeguard was.
– Grape Nuts Flakes absorbs the most milk; Total absorbs the least amount, so will stay crunchiest the longest.
– Ajax is the most effective anti-bacterial soap, followed by Ivory, Equate, Dial, Softsoap and Ivory.
– Soft Choice toilet paper was best in strength, softness, septic tank friendliness and cost effectiveness, followed by Value Soft, then Scott brand.
– Periogard is the most effective mouth bacteria killer with Listerine a close second.
– Chuck’s Donuts had the most fat, followed by Happy Donuts, then Krispy Kreme, then Royal.
– Kleenex Viva paper towels absorb the most orange soday, while Scott towels got the least.
– The best sealant against acid leaks on marble is Kiwi Wet Proof.
– Corian brand cutting boards, along with stainless steel, are the easiest to sanitize.
– The best backpack warmer was Grabber Mycoal brand, followed by EZHeat.
– Adidas Glider is the best performing soccer ball, but price doesn’t necessarily translate to performance. “We hope someone learned something from this because we know we did. … Tim’s father built the contraption from our designs – he was worried we would hurt ourselves with the machinery.”
– The most efficient battery is Energizer Max, followed by Eveready, Rayovac, Duracell, Panasonic, Energizer, Maxell, Sanyo and Duracell Ultra.
Six experiments were specifically commerce-related, but not brand-specific:
– Digital photos are of better quality than regular film.
– Chocolate milk leaves the darkest stain on white baby t-shirts.
– Commercial sunscreen brands are more effective than natural ones.
– Dishwashing detergents are more effective at reducing the surface tension of water than shampoo.
– Artificial fabrics react worse to flame than natural ones.
– Flourescent light bulbs save energy
Another 11 projects were sort of middle of the road product testing/pure science, with some branding mixed in. That means that 38 of 42 projects had some sort of commercial product/brand connection, and of the other four, only two had any non-commercial scientific merit:
– Second-hand smoke has a worse effect on human lungs than first-hand smoke.
– A student constructed a burn glove from generic materials, which sooths, is convenient, easily stored and has other purposes.
And we act shocked. Shocked! At corporate and commercial shenanigans and scandals. Am I going insane? Doesn’t the corporate takeover of our lives bother anyone else? What’s next? Little Amber Britney’s fourth grade science fair baking soda volcano, brought to you by Arm&Hammer? Little Justin Dakota’s third grade science fair radio set, brought to you by Clear Channel Communications? Good lord!
[Silence. Crickets chirping.]
Hmmmmm.
Good night, all.
Bluesky Discussion
View on BlueskyNo replies yet. Be the first to comment on Bluesky!