(No Title)

I Pledge Allegiance To Fundamentalism …

While we’re all probably tired of the whole “Sieg Heil” “Pledge of Allegiance” thing, I thought I would note an article on tompaine.com which pretty much sums things up nicely:

“A Christian socialist who turned his back on religion – that’s the guy whose handiwork politicians of both parties and religious-right leaders rushed to defend this past week. Francis Bellamy, a Baptist minister in upstate New York who sermonized against the materialism of the Gilded Age and who resigned from his church after businessmen cut off funding because of his socialist activities and lectures, wrote the Pledge of Allegiance in 1892. Now his words, composed for a magazine-sponsored school program celebrating the quadricentennial of Columbus Day, are treated as a sacred writ. Holy irony!

“When a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals (based where else but in San Francisco) ruled 2-1 that the pledge is unconstitutional and cannot be recited in public schools because of the ‘under God’ phrase, no microphone on Capitol Hill was safe. Senators and House members scampered before television cameras to denounce this decision. Senator Hillary Clinton said she was ‘offended by the decision.’ House Majority Leader Dick Armey called it ‘one of the most asinine things I ever heard.’ Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle declared it ‘nuts.’ He immediately orchestrated a 99-0 vote in the Senate condemning the decision.

“A hundred or so House members, led by House Speaker Dennis Hastert and House Majority Whip Tom DeLay, put aside such pressing business as raising the debt ceiling (so the United States does not default), overseeing the war on terrorism, crafting the new department for homeland security and developing legislation for a prescription drug benefit to hit the steps of the Capitol and recite the pledge and sing ‘God Bless America.’ From the G8 summit in Canada, George W. Bush bashed the decision as ‘ridiculous.’ Politicians moved to gain political advantage. In Montana, the Republican Senate nominee, Mike Taylor, attacked the Democratic incumbent, Max Baucus, for having once voted against splitting the 9th Circuit Court into two districts. Senate Minority Leader Trent Lott blamed Democrats for not acting quickly enough on Bush’s judicial appointments. And all this was before the gabbers of cable-news land could sink their teeth into the story. Are the politicians and politicos capable of not overreacting to this type of news? (After all, almost every legal expert agrees the decision is likely to be overturned.) Of course not.

“On CNN’s ‘Connie Chung Tonight,’ the eponymous host grilled Michael Newdow, the California parent (or, as The Washington Post called him, ‘the Sacramento atheist’) who brought this case – and argued it himself – because he did not want his daughter to be confronted in her second-grade class each day by a ritual proclaiming there is a God. (The California education code requires public schools to begin the day with an ‘appropriate patriotic exercise,’ and reciting the pledge qualifies as such.) Rather than delve into the meaty legal issues of the case – Is the pledge an endorsement of God? Is asking a child to say the pledge actually a request that the kid affirm monotheism? – Chung inquired of Newdow, ‘Are you proud to be American?,’ and, ‘Are you prepared … [to be] the most hated man in America?’ Newdow argued that he was fighting for the Constitution. To which Chung replied, ‘The whole Pledge of Allegiance has to do with being patriotic and supporting America and supporting the flag.’ Was she not listening? Newdow’s objection was to the ‘under God’ portion of the pledge, not the pledge itself. Chung also suggested Newdow’s pursuit of this case ‘is far more damaging to’ his daughter than having her feel like ‘an outsider’ when the pledge is spoken in her classroom.

…

“It’s no surprise that Falwell would use the occasion to preach fundamentalism and hatred (at least, hatred of judges). Or that flag-waving pols would wrap themselves in the pledge. Or that Bush, the son of a president who made the pledge a key issue in his 1988 campaign against Michael Dukakis, would follow suit. But after Bush had a night to ponder the court’s decision – you think he read it? – he took pledge-mania fundamentalism a giant step further. At the G8 summit, he opened a press conference with Russian president Vladmir Putin by saying, ‘We need common sense judges who understand that our rights were derived from God and those are the kind of judges I intend to put on the bench.’ That is a major – and stunning – policy declaration. Bush was announcing a new litmus test for judges. It’s not just whether you’re a conservative or constructionist (or meet the political needs of Karl Rove, Bush’s uberstrategist). The question is: Do you believe in God, and believe that secular law follows the law of God? In other words, there are no atheists – or agnostics – in Bush’s chambers. Did Bush realize what he was saying? Is he going to ask all potential judicial nominees to tell him their view of God and the derivation of rights? How is this fundamentalism – only believers need apply – different from that of America’s enemies?

“The 9th Circuit Court panel’s decision surely will not stand. Few judges — or justices — are going to challenge the nation’s basic attitudes toward God and patriotism, no matter their constitutional obligations. But praise these two appeal judges — Alfred Goodwin and Stephen Reinhardt – for rendering a gutsy decision and for flushing American fundamentalism into the open. Francis Bellamy would probably tip his hat to them – and then cry over what his pledge has become.”

To which all I can add is, “Yup.”

Good night, ya’ll.