(No Title)

Life In A Small Town Under A Bush-Enronian Moral Climate

Time for a rant.

Rightwinger ditto monkeys are fond, lately, of invoking the term “Clintonian Moral Climate” to explain away pretty much anything bad that has happened since Bill ran for office in 1992, including the year since he left that office. The Whore Street Journal is fond of opining that everything from HIV infection rates to volcanoes in Africa is possible only because a “Clintonian Moral Climate” makes them possible. And further, that now that the Boy King Dictator has restored “honor and integrity to the White House” [snort, choke, laugh out loud] that people are now more moral – that blow jobs and extramarital affairs and evil national health care insurance are no longer possible because the Boy King is on his usurper’s throne.

Whatta crock. With the Boy King on his usurper’s throne, we now are seeing exposed some truly breathtakingly immoral and disgusting shenanigans by corporate America and their political slaves in governors’ mansions, state houses, Congress and the White House. And the Ditto Monkeys say, “Oh, it’s just a business scandal! That’s just The Beauty Of Capitalism! That’s Just The Way The Game Is Played!” To which I say baloney hooey. Morality and Capitalism do not have to be enemies. You don’t have to choose between making money and being moral and just.

It’s time to fight back. Let’s give what’s going on a more accurate label; after all, the moral climate that fosters people like Kenny Boy Lay and Jeff Skilling, the Boy King Dictator and his dad and grandads, etc., needs a label. Shall we call it an Enronian Moral Climate? No, that limits it to just 2001. These shenanigans have been going on for a century. Let’s call it a Bush-Enronian Moral Climate. After all, the Bush crime family is responsible for some truly breathtaking shenanigans for almost a century, spanning three generations. And Enron represents perhaps the worst, most cynical corporate behavior ever, the penultimate millenial example of corporate egregiousness, rape of the democracy and all around moral failure.

But my rant tonight is that the Bush-Enronian Moral Climate of business and politics is not just limited to the national stage. In true “trickle-down” (The ditto monkeys love that concept, so let’s use it ourselves, shall we?) style, the slime seeps down to the lowest levels, even to small towns in the heartland. What is happening in one of my former hometowns, Duncan, Oklahoma, just 80 miles from OKC, truly illustrates this.

I see that the powers-that-be at the medical monolith monopoly known as Duncan Regional Hospital (DRH), including its Kenny Boy-like CEO, are using secretive, backroom shenanigans to get city councils to bend to their will and pass ordinances that prop up the monopoly at the expense of the community – and democracy.

Click here to read the whole sad tale. It’s a surprisingly good piece of journalism, given that my old paper, The Duncan Banner, was bought out by large megacorporations years ago and became just a little local Wal-Mart, a vacuum sucker plunked down into the community to suck advertising/subscriber/classified dollars out and return nothing but a piece of fluff with heavy wire copy, a tiny underpaid news staff – and ultimately a travesty of local journalism. They redeem themselves quite a bit with these two stories, however. Great job, Pat Garnett! I would have been even more impressed with an editorial decrying DRH’s (and the City Council’s) actions, but hey, as I’m fond of saying, “If donkeys fly, you don’t criticize ’em for not staying up there for very long.” In other words, the Donkey Banner flew with two good journalistic efforts. And I’ll leave it at that. Congrats.

But I digress. Here’s the scoop, if you don’t want to read the whole long article. Seems that five of Duncan’s finest doctors got together and have, for two years, planned to build an out-patient surgical clinic for the community because DRH charges too much and doesn’t have enough facilities, etc. (One doctor is completing surgeries as late as 10 p.m., because there aren’t enough facilities to keep up with demand.)

But the doctors didn’t know How The Game Was Played In The Bush-Enronian Moral Climate. Hearing that DRH was planning a $12-million expansion, the doctors decided to be “nice” and inform the hospital of their plans, which might help DRH use the $12 million in other areas. HUGE mistake. Tipped off, the hospital mounted a Bush-Enronian offensive, produced its own study that said the hospital would suffer financially, rounded up city council members and the mayor and played hardball, as if the five doctors were some rogue dealers wanting to encroach on a drug lord’s territory. It was West Side Story all over – the Sharks were movin’ in on the Jets turf and had to be stopped, man.

We’ll let one of Oklahoma’s best surgeons, Dr. Thomas Eiser, tell what happened: “… the doctors went to an October hospital board meeting and presented their ideas to the board. They even invited the hospital to join the venture as an equal partner. ‘But that backfired on us,’ Eiser said. ‘They took some time to look at the proposal. They came back to us with a letter that said ‘No’ to being a partner in the clinic, and the final paragraph of that letter said, ‘We’ll do anything we can to stop this project.’ That’s turned out to be true.’

“The doctors read in the Dec. 10 edition of The Banner that the Dec. 11 city council’s agenda included considering an ordinance that could negatively impact the doctors’ plans to build a free-standing surgical clinic. The doctors believe if it were not for the Open Meeting Act, they would not have found out about the ordinance in time to make any presentation. As it was, they had only a few hours to prepare a rebuttal to the hospital’s claims. ‘Duncan Regional developed the process in secret,’ [one of the doctors said.] ‘It was all done behind closed doors. We didn’t even know the ordinance was going to be discussed at the council meeting until we read about it in the paper one day before the meeting. We couldn’t even get a copy of the resolution until 4 p.m. the day of the council meeting (Dec. 11) … It was all done in a secretive manner. What the city council and Duncan Regional are trying to do is take the choice away from the doctors and the patients.’

[One of the doctors, Gregory] “Hyde said, ‘This was a well orchestrated and well choreographed event, even down to the questions from the city councilmen. Every single point addressed by the councilmen came from the hospital report … There’s no way, unless the councilmen had read the report, that they could have come up with those questions on their own.’

“Eiser said, ‘We feel like it’s been pretty heavy-handed politics, basically.’” Yup, Dr. Eiser, it WAS heavy-handed politics – it was politics in a Bush-Enronian Moral Climate. DRH’s executives are devotees of Karl Rove, the Boy King’s wunderkind. It was a page straight out of his playbook.

The hospital scheduled that city council meeting (well, okay, the City Manager scheduled the meeting – because DRH asked him to) in order to pass an ordinance that makes building such a clinic in Duncan prohibitively expensive. The ordinance was written by DRH (!) and the fee to be charged by the City of Duncan was also set by the hospital:

“The ordinance based its fee on the proposed building and its impact on current medical facilities. [DRH CEO] Robertson said the hospital suggested the fee for the feasibility study should be $100,000. Based on the hospital’s studies, he believes the cost for the studies could exceed the amount recommended by the ordinance, which is a $2,500 base fee and 1 percent of the proposed building costs. ‘Based on our experience with feasibility studies, $100,000 was a reasonable amount for what those services would cost,’ he said. ‘We felt that much was required to ensure the city had the funding for the studies. If all the money was not used, it would be given back.’” This even though Oklahoma law doesn’t require such studies, and the doctors had already done their homework.

Friggin’ unbelievable. It was a beautiful, cynical, nuclear blast – political hardball which accomplishes the gutting of the competition, but preserves a great propaganda line to sell to the community that DRH is screwing. And it gets better.

The DRH CEO also had the gall to tell Dr. Hyde, just the way things will be in HIS town: “Hyde said he went to … Robertson … about his patients’ complaints about the high cost of surgeries. He said he told Robertson he and the other physicians thought they could perform many procedures at almost one-half the cost charged by the hospital. ‘The reason they are charging the high prices is because they can,’ Hyde said. ‘There’s no competitive pressure to do otherwise, and I’m tired of my patients bearing the brunt of the inefficiencies of the hospital. When I talked with … (Robertson) about it, he told me, ‘The day you open a surgical center is the day our prices will be lower.’ If they can charge less, why aren’t they doing it now?’” In other words, since the fix with the City of Duncan was already in, he knows DRH can continue charge whatever they want for any procedure, ’cause ain’t no clinic gon’ be built in this-yere county, and DRH will continue to operate in an inefficient, monopolistic way, preferring to kick ass down at City Hall rather than do the right thing for the 40,000 citizens of Stephens County.

A second article details the doctors’ side of the story and their reaction. They are, of course, feeling raw and royally screwed. Let’s just call them simply naive, ’cause they didn’t Play The Game The Way It’s Supposed To Be Played, nor were they aware that they were operating in that Bush-Enronian Moral Climate, up against executives and board members who would feel more at home in Enron’s board room, at at a White House staff meeting than they are in tiny little Duncan, Oklahoma. Good lord! Why the hell are they working for DRH?! They should’ve been auditing for Arthur Andersen or kicking employee ass at Enron with Kenny Boy! Holy cow, they’re masters!

They’re also busily visiting city councils everywhere in Duncan’s trade area, making sure that the doctors are prevented from building anywhere close to DRH. Which leaves just who in the dust? Well, if they don’t get fired or terrorized by the vengeful DRH board and executives, the doctors should be fine. But anyone needing surgical services in Stephens County? S. C. R. E. W. E. D. screwed. Also screwed are the rest of us in the country who face ever-rising, ever-restrictive insurance nonsense because medical facilities (and Bush-Enronian hospital executives like Dave Robertson) charge just as much as they can possibly can and stay out of jail. If this is just what goes on in little Duncan, what happens in the thousands of other towns and cities across the country? And just why are medical expenses so enormous? Because uninsured people need medical care for which they can’t pay? Or could it just be because of Bush-Enronian organizations like Duncan Regional Hospital and their political sidekicks on city councils, medical boards, state legislatures, governors’ mansions, the White House and Congress? Hmmmm.

The rightwingers would just snort at me and call all this “the beauty of capitalism and unfettered free markets.” I call it what it is: Criminal cronyism, subversion of democracy, amoral, immoral, unethical, disgusting and indefensible – in other words, Bush-Enronian. DRH’s manipulation of the Duncan City Council, Manager and Mayor also smacks of a Stalinist system – DRH is supposedly non-profit, but freedom of medical choice, democracy, etc., are verboten and anyone who wishes to think outside the monopoly box is crushed like a bug.

It is, unfortunately, the way things have been done many times over in Duncan, America. Local government has always been a boosterish, rubber stamp extension of whoever wielded the biggest bucks: For most of the 20th century, it was the Halliburton City Council; for years, Halliburton has leeched off the city, polluted its ground, destroyed its roads with their trucks, manipulated its ordinances and political processes – and treated its workers, the citizens, as toys to be played with, which are tossed away once their usefulness is outlived. Now that city council tends to veer from being the Wal-Mart City Council, to the DRH City Council, to the Family Dollar Warehouse City Council. Almost never has it truly been the People of Duncan’s City Council.

A final note: While I have to congratulate DRH staff, doctors and nurses for the tremendous improvements in their operations and the great advances in medical services they’ve brought Stephens County, this latest shenanigan by the executives is just plain wrong. DRH has indeed improved from the facility that operated an emergency room with incredibly incompetent Fort Sill army doctors who once told my sister and brother-in-law that, if my two-month-old, pneumonia-stricken niece “stopped breathing, just bring her back.” Now pause for a moment and let that statement sink in. “If she stops breathing, bring her back.” Fortunately, that two-month-old survived DRH’s incompetence and is now a beautiful, competent 20-year-old who works in the hospital’s rehab center – but no thanks to the DRH ER of 1981.

So congrats on turning that whole thing around. But you should figure something out: Continued hard work and service to everyone in Stephens County, regardless of financial and social condition, and complete respect for democracy and true capitalistic competition, should be your mission, not a disgusting rape of Duncan’s local democracy and finances in the name of making a buck. Shame on you, every one!

Good night ya’ll.