Some Notes About The Insane Rants Of Yesterday
My S.O. noting that I sound a bit “insane” and that the part below about Machine Gun Annie holding Barbara Olson’s hand to comfort her as they rode American 77 on 9/11 was “a bit over the top” or some such words to that effect reminded me that I forgot to include a little tidbit – the thing that caused me to write the above little jewel in the first place.
Seems that Ben Fritz recently reported on Spinsanity.com that Mark Steyn, a rightwingnut compadre of MG Annie’s at National Review Online, was writing about “what he calls the ‘more slippery variety’ of ‘anti-Americanism’ here in the U.S. Amongst his examples is a letter to the editor in a small-town New Hampshire newspaper. The writer, Robert Daubenspeck, suggests that the U.S. should not retaliate militarily, but respond with love. Steyn’s response to this at worst naïve sentiment is chilling: ‘It would be mean-spirited to regret that Mr. Daubenspeck was not given the opportunity to test his thesis with one of the hijackers on American Airlines Flight 11.’“
Fritz notes, “We have truly reached a scary point in American political discourse when writers in respected publications hint at regret that those they disagree with did not die in a terrorist attack.“
And that’s what got me going. Seems it’s okay for a rightwingnut like Steyn or MG Annie to write gleefully about political dissenters dying violently, but God forbid one of those L-word people do. I’m just making a point, folks, in other words. No, not even a seriously disgusting, reprehensible character such as MG Annie should die a horrible death. Nor Barbara Olson. Nor anyone on the planet, not just America. Of course not!
But I simply get pretty sick of the nauseatingly violent, barbaric, uncivilized, rightwing fascist rhetoric that has taken over in American political discourse. And it’s not simply new since 9/11. Nope. These are the same rightwingers who called for Chelsea Clinton to be murdered, because she was carrying the genes of Bill and Hillary. How truly mentally unbalanced is someone who writes these things about political opponents? Well, I’m not a psychiatrist, so don’t ask me. You could ask people like Traudl Jung, Hitler’s personal secretary, though. She’s quite the expert.
It’s simply that, as a student of history, particularly European history of the 1870-1945 period, I get very nervous, and very angry, when I hear things that echo Nazi rhetoric from the Fascist 30’s.
And speaking of the Fascist 30’s, it occurred to me earlier after my post below that I’m quite seriously bugged about Andrew Sullivan, especially, invoking George Orwell and calling American pacifists “fifth columnists” – all of which evoke concepts of the Spanish Civil War. So here’s a further rant about that fruitcake, vis a vis Orwell.
It’s not the first time that the American rightwingers have bastardized and perverted historical icons to try put a stamp of legitimacy on their political beliefs. After all, they repeatedly invoke the name of the Founding Fathers to support everything from the laughable concept that America was intended to be a religious fundamentalist theocracy (read Paine’s The Age of Reason) to trickle-down economics and corporate oligarchy. But good god, now they’re invoking Orwell, a man who wrote two scathing satires ripping apart totalitarianism in any form, be it from the left or the right, to make a case for getting everyone in lockstep with a national totalitarian agenda – bombing the hell out of Afghanistan. He’s been used to make a spurious case against handgun control by the National Rifle Association, but that’s small potatoes compared to what our boy Andy is now writing.
Let’s sort of superficially and quickly explore some biographical details about Mr. Orwell, nee Eric Blair, because I’m pretty sure Andy hasn’t. Or at least didn’t grasp anything about what he read. From the George Orwell website comes the following tidbits:
1. “In 1927, while home on leave [from the Indian Imperial Police], he resigned. There [were] at least two reasons for this: Firstly, his life as a policeman was a distraction from the life he really wanted, which was to be a writer; and secondly, he had come to feel that, as a policeman in Burma, he was supporting a political system in which he could no longer believe. Even as early as this his ideas about writing and his political ideas were closely linked. It was not simply that he wished to break away from British Imperialism in India: he wished to ‘escape from … every form of man’s dominion over man,’ as he said in Road to Wigan Pier (1937), and the social structure out of which he came dependent, he saw it, on just that ‘dominion over others’ – not just over the Burmese, but over the English working class.“
2. “… Orwell’s reasons for taking the name Orwell are much more complicated than those writers usually have when adopting a pen-name. In effect it meant that Eric Blair would somehow have to shed his old identity and take on a new. This is exactly what he tried to do: he tried to change himself from Eric Blair, old Etonian and English colonial policemen, into George Orwell, classless antiauthoritarian.“
3. Upon his arrival in Spain to write about and participate in the Civil War, “There was a shortage of everything, but there was equality. Orwell joined in the struggle, by enlisting in the militia of POUM (Partido Obrero de Unificación de Marxista), which was associated with the British Labour Party. For the first time in his life socialism seemed reality, something for which it was worth fighting for.” Unfortunately, after being wounded, “Three and a half months later when he returned to Barcelona, he found it a changed city. No longer a place where the socialist word ‘comrade’ was really felt to mean something, it was a city returning to ‘normal.’ Even worse, he was to find that the group he was with, the POUM, was now accused of being a Fascist militia, secretly helping Franco. Orwell had to sleep in the open to avoid showing his papers, and eventually managed to escape into France with his wife. His experiences in Spain left two impressions on Orwell’s mind: Firstly, they showed him that socialism in action was a human possibility, if only a temporary one. He never forgot the exhilaration of those first days in Barcelona , when a new society seemed possible, where ‘comradeship’ instead of being just a socialist abuse of language, was reality. But secondly, he saw the experience of the city returning to ‘normal’ as a gloomy confirmation of the fact that there will always be different classes, that there is something in the human nature that seeks violence, conflict, power over others. It is clear that these two impressions, of hope on the one hand, and despair on the other are entirely contradictionary. Nevertheless, despite the despair and confusion of his return to Barcelona (there were street fights between different groups of socialists), Orwell left Spain with a hopeful impression. “
Yup, Andy, really sounds like Orwell would have appreciated you invoking his name in your liberal-bashing, patriotic witchhunt. I personally think the aristocratic Eric Blair would have had the servants remove you bodily from the drawing room; the proletarian George Orwell would have kicked your snotty little ass back to your mummy in merry old England where you belong.
And by the way, what’re you, Mr. Sullivan, doing, other than screaming for blood? Have you enlisted in the British Army? Royal Air Force? Special Forces? Volunteered as a medic to go to the front lines? Made plans to go drive ambulances, dig trenches, be an orderly in a Red Cross hospital, serve time in any one of dozens of Afghani refugee camps in Pakistan which will be burgeoning with the human refuse caused by your much-desired military smashmouth? Gonna work in a munitions factory? Oh, I forgot. You’ll stay safely at home and “entertain the troops” and feel like your doing your bit in the War on Terrorism. ‘Course, you’ll probably bugger ’em bareback and send ’em back to the front with “the gift,” but I digress.
“If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face – forever.” – George Orwell, 1984. Well, Raggedy Ann and Andy, thanks for ushering us into the future.
Finally, and then no more on these two worthless harpies: Sullivan seeks to spread that old “fifth column” bullshit (that is so 1960s honey! Get over it!) and tie it to Orwell denouncing WWII British pacifists in a fit of patriotic rhetoric when it appeared the hakenkreuz would soon be flying from London’s lampposts and Churchill’s head would be stuck up on a pike outside the Tower. Then tries to tar post-9/11 American pacifists with the same brush. Oh, the tangled web we weave, when first we spin and dodge and deceive, Andy. First, the “fifth column” was a Spanish Civil War term; with four fascist/Nationalist armed columns approaching Madrid, rebel sympathizers in the city did all they could to aid the approaching Franco, hence the term “fifth column.” It’s completely specious to link that with post-9/11 pacifists saying that we shouldn’t nuke Afghanistan in response. It’s simply irresponsible to assert that those who are saying, “Don’t kill innocent Afghanis who have already suffered 23 unremitting years of war, terror, bloodshed and death,” actively, physically assisted 19 hijackers in crashing four airliners on 9/11. Secondly, post-9/11 American Doves are hardly in the same class with propagandist Lord Haw-Haw and the members of British Fascist Party, who were pretty damn far from being pacifists or leftists. Talk about intellectual dishonesty in the pursuit of a political agenda!
But hey! What’s a little intellectual dishonesty when it scores the propaganda points you need? Let’s listen to the masters, who can explain it all better than I:
“All propaganda has to be popular and has to adapt its spiritual level to the perception of the least intelligent of those towards whom it intends to direct itself.” Says Adolf Hitler in Volume I of Mein Kampf.
“…there was no point in seeking to convert the intellectuals. For intellectuals would never be converted and would anyway always yield to the stronger, ‘and this will always be the man in the street.’ Arguments must therefore be crude, clear and forcible, and appeal to emotions and instincts, not the intellect. Truth was unimportant and entirely subordinate to tactics and psychology … Hatred and contempt must be directed at particular individuals.” Hugh Trevor-Roper writing on Josef Goebbels, The Goebbels Diaries, p. XX.
Well, Josef and Raggedy Ann and Andy, call me one of The Unconvertibles.
And on that intensely scary note, children, I’m off to bed.