(No Title)

Chain Letters

Someone passed on the following to me yesterday:

“As a seventh grade student, Claire Nelson learned that di (ethylhexyl) adepate (DEHA), considered a carcinogen, is found in plastic wrap. She also learned that the FDA had never studied the effect of microwave cooking on plastic-wrapped food. Claire began to wonder: ‘Can cancer-causing particles seep into food covered with household plastic wrap while it is being microwaved?’ Three years later, with encouragement from her high school science teacher, Claire set out to test what the FDA had not. Although she had an idea for studying the effect of microwave radiation on plastic-wrapped food, she did not have the equipment. Eventually, Jon Wilkes at the National Center for Toxicological Research in Jefferson, Arkansas, agreed to help her. The research center, which is affiliated with the FDA, let her use its facilities to perform her experiments, which involved microwaving plastic wrap in virgin olive oil. Claire tested four different plastic wraps and ‘found not just the carcinogens but also xenoestrogen was migrating [into the oil] …’ Xenoestrogens are linked to low sperm counts in men and to breast cancer in women. … Dioxins are carcinogens and highly toxic to the cells of our bodies. Instead, he recommends using glass, Corning Ware, or ceramic containers for heating food. You get the same results without the dioxins. So such things as TV dinners, instant saimin and soups, etc., should be removed from the container and heated in something else. Paper isn’t bad but you don’t know what is in the paper. Just safer to use tempered glass, Corning Ware, etc. He said we might remember when some of the fast food restaurants moved away from the foam containers to paper. The dioxin problem is one of the reasons. Pass this on to your friends. … To add to this: Saran wrap placed over foods as they are nuked, with the high heat, actually drips poisonous toxins into the food. Use paper towel instead.”

Well, interesting. And I don’t dispute that it’s partially true. But there’s just something about chain letters that gets to me. And so I wrote the following admittedly a bit cranky response:

It’s always interesting getting these chain e-mails. They’re just like chain letters, and even include the “pass this on to everyone you know” tag lines. The only difference between a chain e-mail and a chain letter is that chain e-mails don’t specifically say that you will have bad luck if you don’t pass them on. I guess that it is implied that you get bad luck if you don’t pass on the e-mail or heed its advice; in other words, if you don’t pass on this e-mail and your loved ones use plastic wrap in the microwave, they will get cancer and die. But I digress.

I usually check e-mails like this out with Snopes.com (which is dedicated to debunking urban legends like the one about the old lady who put her poodle in the microwave to dry it out) and other online, reputable sources and most turn out to be hoaxes or urban legends or just plain untrue. Jan Harold Brundvald has a series of books debunking urban legends and tracing their sources; they have titles such as “The Choking Doberman” (dog has thief’s finger stuck in throat) and “The Mexican Pet” (lady thinks she’s bringing chihuahua back from Mexico, but it’s actually a rat.) It’s all fascinating reading. It’s the journalist in me, I guess. Plus, we all know I have too much free time on my hands. So forgive me for the length of this thing, but if you’re interested in knowing more, then bear with me and keep reading:

The big problem with this chain e-mail is that it cites as one of its sources a Dr. Edward Fujimoto. At the web address http://www.snopes2.com/toxins/plastic.htm, we find the following information: “We point out here that the ‘Dr. Edward Fujimoto’ identified in this [chain e-mail] piece is not a staff physician from ‘Castle Hospital’ or a medical doctor; he’s a PhD serving as director of the Center for Health Promotion at Castle Medical Center in Kailua, Hawaii.” Okay, so the first part of the e-mail is only sorta kinda half true. That rings alarm bells right there.

Snopes.com investigators then get to the meat of the thing: “Is there really something to the central claim of this e-mail, that heating plastic in microwaves releases a cancer-causing agent into the food? It’s within the realm of possibility, but it must be stressed the FDA does impose stringent regulations on plastics meant for microwaving. Also, if there are dioxins lurking in the plastic containers we heat food in and the process of warming those receptacles looses those nasties into our ingestibles, we’ve yet to locate the studies that prove this. However, because most dioxins are dangerous compounds we want to have as little to do with as possible, many people are cautious about using anything associated with them. So, if you’re one of the concerned, be sure that when you cover a dish you intend to microwave with ordinary plastic wrap you do not let the covering touch the food, because some of the plasticizer in the wrap – which may contain toxic chemicals, as opposed to does contain toxic chemicals – could migrate to what you’re cooking, especially foods high in fat. Alternatively, use waxed paper for this purpose. Those who are very, very cautious about the potential for dioxin contamination might choose to adopt the central point of the e-mail’s advice, which is to decant all items into glass or ceramic containers before microwaving. But how real is this concern? According to Dr. George Pauli, a leading Food and Drug Administration scientist, not very. He acknowledged that some plasticizers do migrate into foods, particularly those containing a lot of fat, oil, or sugars. But research has found no ill effects from consumption of plasticizers in FDA-approved plastic wraps, Pauli said. Even so, others remain unconvinced, and those on both sides of the issue recommend not letting the wrap touch the food.”

What is also interesting is that Claire Nelson’s research is only located in one scientific paper, which is only mentioned on the FDA website (not published where you can read it), and is located nowhere else on the Web that I could find. Her research has not been replicated by professional scientists and she was at the time of her original study, after all, a high school student, as reported in a 1998 Associated Press story at http://www.california.com/~hawk/MicrowaveCancerPlastics.htm. Since 1999, she’s apparently been a student at Hendrix College (http://www.hendrix.edu/news/1999/nelson.htm).

So basically, what we have here, bottom line, is a chain e-mail that has been circulating the ether for the last four years, based upon a high school science fair experiment, that may or may not prove to be true, but “be careful with plastic wrap in the microwave just in case.” I personally have always used paper towels in the microwave, and usually also use regular dishes, not plastic ones. I just didn’t want the plastic melting into my food. Chemical contamination hadn’t occurred to me, but I guess anything is possible. I try to eliminate as many carcinogens as possible.

But I think the more important thing here is: Treat almost every chain e-mail like this that you receive with a healthy dose of skepticism and a grain of salt. Some like this one turn out to be sort of half-true; others are more egregious. For instance, someone last month forwarded to me the infamous “The Military Salutes Dubya Bush And Faces Him; During The Clinton Years, They Saluted, But Turned Their Faces Because They Hated Him” e-mail. It was an interesting story, but it was just that … a story. It’s completely untrue and incredibly disrespectful to the professionalism of the Marine Corps, by using the presidential Marine detail to score Clinton-hating points. In fact, members of the military are just as likely to be Dubya-haters as they are Clinton-haters; witness the suspension of an Army officer in Monterey, CA, a month or two ago for accusing Bush in the newspaper of knowing 9/11 was going to happen beforehand and allowing it to happen anyway.

The “Marines Salute Dubya Differently” chain e-mail was actually only a section of a column written by an ultra-rightwing radio commentator in Virginia named George Caylor (who would make Rush Limbaugh and Fox News blush); the commentator is one of a stable of writers funded by the infamous Richard Mellon Scaife. The rest of the column, which isn’t forwarded as part of the chain e-mail, uses some, shall we say, unflattering, uncomplimentary, “nasty” names for Hillary Clinton, among other things. In other words, it’s not as high-minded and moral and decent as the e-mail tries to make it out to be. Regardless of how you feel about Hillary, calling a former first lady and United States Senator a “rhymes with witch” is hardly moral, Christian behavior and writing.

Furthermore, the columnist’s connection to Scaife is particularly greasy. Scaife, Pittsburgh heir to the immense Mellon fortune, funded with millions of dollars the infamous Arkansas Project, the long effort to smear the Clintons with anything that would stick – a propaganda effort which gave us the Whitewater investigation that consumed nine years and $100 million taxpayer dollars and resulted in exoneration of the Clintons on all Whitewater charges. It was Scaife’s Arkansas Project, for example, which gave us the infamous TrooperGate allegations; those troopers themselves later recanted and admitted they trumped the whole thing up – at the urging of those involved in Scaife’s Arkansas Project. The Project also gave us the completely discredited allegations that Clinton was running drugs out of the Mena, AR, airport. On a side note, one of the politicians involved with Scaife’s Arkansas Project is Ted Olson, who was rewarded by Bush with the plum assignment of Solicitor General of the United States and who is now in charge of representing the people of the United States before the Supreme Court.

Anyway, back to the chain e-mail. The Snopes.com investigators spoke with several Marines, who had this to say:

“If the question is ‘Did the Marines who greeted the President willfully show disrespect by failing to execute a ‘facing’ movement after the salute?’ the answer is no.

“Proper protocol is for the Marine to snap a salute to the President. The President may or may not return the salute at his discretion. If the President returns the salute, the Marine immediately ‘cuts’ or ‘posts’ by bringing his arm sharply down to his side from the salute and remaining at a position of attention. If the President does not return the salute, the Marine will wait until the President passes him, then he will cut and remain at a position of attention. This is the protocol when greeting a senior officer, including the President.”

Snopes adds: [The e-mail is a] “snappy little story. It has only two problems:

“‘It’s absolutely false,’ says Staff Sgt. Keith Milks of the public affairs office at Marine Corps headquarters.

“If it was true, the Marines would see it as an insult to their own honor, not to Bill Clinton. Milks said crew members of the presidential helicopter ‘are chosen for their professionalism.’

“In a phone interview, Milks said crew members of HM-1 – Marine One, the presidential helicopter – had followed the same protocol with Clinton that they used for all presidents, to wit:

“The Marine at the bottom of the steps salutes the debarking president. As soon as the salute is returned, the Marine does a right face to face the president’s back. The Marine holds that position until the president ‘has moved a comfortable distance away,’ Milks said.

“Even if one dislikes the man who is currently President, protocol dictates that he be shown the proper respect in order not to dishonor the office of President of the United States. Marines know that as well as anyone.”

In other words, this chain e-mail just amounts to a smear on the honor and professionalism of the Marine Corps – it insults the presidential Marine detail in alleging that they would act less than professionally, less than honorably. The important thing here is NOT how one feels about Clinton OR Bush; lies, smears, slanderous attacks on the Marine Corps and the OFFICE of the presidency are no more moral and decent than Bill’s private behavior with Monica or George W’s 1971 funding of his girlfriend’s abortion in Houston. A sin is a sin – sure, murder is worse than bilking investors out of millions of dollars, but both will send you straight to hell. An e-mail like that simply diminishes us all and brings us down into the muck with them.

Long story short: Be careful with what you get in your e-mail in box. And investigate, investigate, investigate for yourself – don’t take anything at face value.

I highly recommend snopes.com. It’s got a lot of great information, including an entire section on lore surrounding Coca-Cola (True: Coke did originally contain cocaine; False: the cursive script of the label includes an image of a person snorting cocaine; only two people know the formula and each of them only knows half of it; and it was originally green; Half true sorta kinda: Coca-Cola in chinese means “bite the wax tadpole” – in some places, yes, but in 1928, Coke adopted characters for their name which actually mean, “to allow the mouth to be able to rejoice.” And so on.)

Now, I wasn’t trying to be cranky with that response, but I may have come across as so. If so, I apologize, but I was very interested in the story behind the story. Didn’t mean to be cranky. But chain e-mails and spam are the scourge of our online existence. And that does sometimes makes me cranky.

Good night, ya’ll.