(No Title)

Jefferson’s Prescient Wisdom (And Some of Bukunin’s and Chomsky’s)

Today, I ran across these two tidbits, in an interview with Noam Chomsky on ZMag.com. Chomsky is under vicious fire from the fascists right now, along with Susan Sontag and Bill Maher. Who said politics makes strange bedfellows? Anyone under fire from the Fascists is someone who I’m interested in getting to know better. Anyway, he talks about Jefferson’s world view. It’s very interesting, and shows Jefferson’s long-range wisdom. He was definitely not stupid.

Says Chomsky in Defective Democracy: “[Jefferson] made a distinction between two groups – aristocrats and democrats. Aristocrats ‘fear and distrust the people, and wish to draw all powers from them into the hands of the higher classes.’ This view is held by respectable intellectuals in many different societies today, and is quite similar to the Leninist doctrine that the vanguard party of radical intellectuals should take power and lead the stupid masses to a bright future. Most liberals are aristocrats in Jefferson’s sense. [Former Secretary of State] Henry Kissinger is an extreme example of an aristocrat.

“Democrats, Jefferson wrote, ‘identify with the people, have confidence in them, cherish and consider them as the most honest and safe, although not the most wise, depository of the public interest.’ In other words, democrats believe the people should be in control, whether or not they’re going to make the right decisions. Democrats do exist today, but they’re becoming increasingly marginal.

“Jefferson specifically warned against ‘banking institutions and monied incorporations’ (what we would now call ‘corporations’) and said that if they grow, the aristocrats will have won and the American Revolution will have been lost. Jefferson’s worst fears were realized (although not entirely in the ways he predicted).

“Later on, [the Russian anarchist Mikhail] Bakunin predicted that the contemporary intellectual classes would separate into two groups (both of which are examples of what Jefferson meant by aristocrats). One group, the ‘red bureaucracy,’ would take power into their own hands and create one of the most malevolent and vicious tyrannies in human history.

“The other group would conclude that power lies in the private sector, and would serve the state and private power in what we now call state capitalist societies. They’d ‘beat the people with the people’s stick,’ by which he meant that they’d profess democracy while actually keeping the people in line.“

Chomsky also makes the following points, which are worth some thought:

“Over long periods, the involvement of the public in planning or implementation of public policy has been quite marginal. This is a business-run society. The political parties have reflected business interests for a long time.

“One version of this view which I think has a lot of power behind it is what political scientist Thomas Ferguson calls ‘the investment theory of politics.’ He believes that the state is controlled by coalitions of investors who join together around some common interest. To participate in the political arena, you must have enough resources and private power to become part of such a coalition.

“Since the early nineteenth century, Ferguson argues, there’s been a struggle for power among such groups of investors. The long periods when nothing very major seemed to be going on are simply times when the major groups of investors have seen more or less eye to eye on what public policy should look like. Moments of conflict come along when groups of investors have differing points of view.

“During the New Deal, for example, various groupings of private capital were in conflict over a number of issues. Ferguson identifies a high-tech, capital-intensive, export-oriented sector that tended to be quite pro-New Deal and in favor of the reforms. They wanted an orderly work force and an opening to foreign trade.

“A more labor-intensive, domestically oriented sector, grouped essentially around the National Association of Manufacturers, was strongly anti-New Deal. They didn’t want any of these reform measures. (Those groups weren’t the only ones involved, of course. There was the labor movement, a lot of public ferment and so on.)“

In a separate part of the interview entitled, “Keeping The Rich On Welfare, Chomsky notes the following about corporate welfare:

“Under Reagan, the US managed to drive labor costs way below the level of our competitors (except for Britain). That’s produced consequences not only in Mexico and the US but all across the industrial world.

“For example, one of the effects of the so-called free trade agreement with Canada was to stimulate a big flow of jobs from Canada to the southeast US, because that’s an essentially nonunion area. Wages are lower; you don’t have to worry about benefits; workers can barely organize. So that’s an attack against Canadian workers.

“Daimler-Benz, which is Germany’s biggest conglomerate, was seeking essentially Third World conditions. They managed to get our southeastern states to compete against one another to see who could force the public to pay the largest bribe to bring them there. Alabama won. It offered hundreds of millions of dollars in tax benefits, practically gave Daimler-Benz the land on which to construct their plant, and agreed to build all sorts of infrastructure for them.

“Some people will benefit – the small number who are employed at the plant, with some spillover to hamburger stands and so on, but primarily bankers, corporate lawyers, people involved in investment and financial services. They’ll do very well, but the cost to most of the citizens of Alabama will be substantial.

“Even the Wall Street Journal, which is rarely critical of business, pointed out that this is very much like what happens when rich corporations go to Third World countries, and it questioned whether there were going to be overall benefits for the state of Alabama. Meanwhile Daimler-Benz can use this to drive down the lifestyle of German workers.

“German corporations have also set up factories in the Czech Republic, where they can get workers for about 10% the cost of German workers. The Czech Republic is right across the border; it’s a Westernized society with high educational levels and nice white people with blue eyes. Since they don’t believe in the free market any more than any other rich people do, they’ll leave the Czech Republic to pay the social costs, pollution, debts and so on, while they pick up the profits.

“It’s exactly the same with the plants GM is building in Poland, where it’s insisting on 30% tariff protection. The free market is for the poor. We have a dual system – protection for the rich and market discipline for everyone else.“

What sweetheart deals. What suckers.

Bluesky Discussion

View on Bluesky

No replies yet. Be the first to comment on Bluesky!