(No Title)

Edward R. Murrow Would Have Smacked Andrew Sullivan From Here Back To London

Still reading the anthology of World War II journalism, Reporting World War II, put together by the advisory board of Samuel Hynes, Anne Matthews, Nancy Caldwell Sorel and Roger J. Spiller.

It’s enough to make you cry.

Journalism has slid so far down into an abyss of corporate-controlled slime since the war, and it’s extremely apparent when you read this anthology.

Contained within are reports from some of America’s finest all-time great journalists, men and women such as William Shirer, A.J. Liebling, Edward R. Murrow, Ernie Pyle, Howard K. Smith, Annalee Jacoby, Helen Lawrenson, E.B. White, John Steinbeck, Margaret Bourke-White, Bill Mauldin, Robert Sherrod and John Hersey. And many others.

When you read what these journalists wrote, you realize that no one writing today can even come close – millennial American journalists are a bunch of hacks, writing lazy PR fluff, celebrity trash, meekly going where and writing what others tell them to, kowtowing to the bottom line dictated by the corporate board room.

Also a tragedy is seeing the kind of access and participation that American war correspondents had to the field; Tom Lea going over the side and hitting the beach at Peleliu under fire in September 1944, yards behind the first waves of Marines chewing up beaches and killing Japs. Murrow riding a Lancaster bomber on a 1943 raid on Berlin. Margaret Bourke-White taking photos from an artillery-spotting Piper Cub in 1943 over Italy.

And what do we have today? SecDec Dr. Strangelove Rummy tells reporters what the line of the day is and they report it. Did reporters ride B-52s as they pounded the Afghanistan hills? Were reporters present aboard American warships as they lobbed cruise missiles at Kabul? Were reporters crouching behind Special Forces troops as they cleared caves near Tora Bora? Good lord no! The American people might get the truth about war and that, since Vietnam, is a bad thing. That means that Democracy might get prejudiced by the media against the killing machine and then want the killing to stop.

So reporters are now nothing more than teletype machines, spitting out whatever copy the imperial government wishes to be spit out.

Sad.

And vomit-inducing. To think that William Shirer endured all the years of living in the Third Reich under totalitarian conditions to report to America what was going on. To think that Murrow flew on those bombers and reported from London while the Blitz was raining down on his head. To think that Tom Lea hit the beach at Peleliu in the middle of one of the Pacific’s most bitter fights. And all of them part of the effort to shine the light of freedom and democracy on the darkness of totalitarianism. To think that journalism’s finest hour has devolved in a short half-century into what it has become: Endless reports on sex and celebrities; endless wranglings over liberals versus conversatives; endless regurgitation of the pap planted by political operatives in places of power.

We’ve gone from Edward R. Murrow dodging flak over Berlin to Andrew Sullivan’s sex-obsessions, culture warring and barebacking. Margaret Bourke-White’s challenging sexism and dodging the Luftwaffe over Italy to Ann Coulter’s lunatic and irresponsible mindless rantings. From William Shirer’s principled, scholarly and intellectual analysis of a totalitarian regime to Geraldo Rivera’s manufacturing facts and pretending to dodge bullets. Instead of Brendan Gill’s mesmerizing portrait of an Army Air Corps bombardier, we get Larry King’s pandering to celebrities shilling worthless tell-all books or insipid tripe passing as motion pictures.

If 1933-45 was American journalism’s finest hour, then the turn of the Millennium must surely be American journalism’s lowest, most worthless, point.

I can’t decide if the Boy King George’s administration has destroyed the First Amendment’s free press provision through a full-frontal external assault or if it was destroyed through an internal cancer which has eaten it alive from within.

Either way, millennial American journalism, particularly when compared with that of World War II, is lost.

They aren’t journalists; they’re PR flacks, shilling for whatever bullet point a government official or corporate officer wishes to emphasize today.

I’m glad Shirer and Murrow and Bourke-White didn’t live to see all this.

Bluesky Discussion

View on Bluesky

No replies yet. Be the first to comment on Bluesky!